Maybe populationyou? We're medium-paced, no memory loss, no AU. If horror's not your bag, we're probably not the game for you, though.

Population: You is based directly on Silent Hill, and we have Nightmare events where player characters have to deal with Silent Hill monsters and the town actively trying to kill them. Then we do a more relaxed Daytime event, where the town is only passively trying to kill everyone in it.

There are nerfs, though nobody's been completely nerfed yet.