Hello! Might I suggest illmet? It only just opened this month and while it is invite-only, the TDM is open to all and players are allowed to invite people right off of the TDM itself.

Ill Met by Moonlight is jamjar game pretty much about terrible faeries in that kidnap people to be their servants. It has elements of fantasy, body horror, and memory loss, and though it does take canon powers away on entry, everyone can learn small spells and swap memories for more advanced magic over time. It's slow and small right now, since it just started, and the AC can be from logs, network posts, and even the test drive itself.